South Mountain Creamery, Middletown

I absolutely love our weekly deliveries from South Mountain Creamery. It's an easy solution to the desire to eat local. It's easy to use their online portal to order one time or recurring orders and to edit your orders. You'll get a text when your order is dropped off so you can bring everything inside promptly. We get farm fresh milk and eggs weekly and sometimes add in other goodies. The meals you can order are tasty and they offer a wide selection of produce, meats, dairy, and baked goods.

Where do I even begin!! I am a baker/caterer always looking for local ingredients for my foods! On a visit to the Amish Market, I discovered South Mountain Creamery’s amazing unsalted butter tubs! I have not used any other butter since! I then found their website and learned that they offered home delivery right to my door! I now use the eggs, butter, buttermilk and cheese for my catering/bakery business!!! I also buy ground beef and Turkey, steaks and chicken breasts and my family love them! I can honestly say that there is a tremendous difference between the quality of the meat and poultry from South Mountain vs. those packaged as grass-fed/Organic in big grocery stores. I plan to visit the farm this summer to see exactly where these great products are being made and packaged! I look forward to the new products that being rolled out! I’m so happy to have found them!!